These Soft Sourdough Sandwich Rolls are a perfect fusion of tangy sourdough goodness and the comforting familiarity of a soft sandwich roll. Prepare to roll up your sleeves, gather your ingredients, and elevate your sandwich game!
Using a bowl of a stand mixer equipped with a dough hook, . Allow the mixer to knead the mixture on low speed for 5-10 minutes until the dough pulls away from the bowl's sides and achieves a stretchy consistency.
To determine its readiness, perform the 'window pane' test. Take a small piece of dough and pinch it, then gently stretch and manipulate it into a somewhat rectangular shape. The dough, resembling a transparent window pane, should become thin enough to see through. If the dough breaks instead of stretching, it might require more kneading. We want to finish with the elastic dough at the end of the kneading (shaggy dough won't rise well).
Place in a greased bowl (a mixing bowl is fine, it doesn't need to be a large bowl) and cover with plastic wrap, aluminum foil, a tight lid, or (what I like to do) a plastic bag. Alternatively, let the dough rise in the bowl of your standing mixer, but be prepared to stick to it a little. You don’t want to cover the dough with just a damp towel; it will dry overnight and leave you with an unpleasant crust on the dough.
Allow the dough to do the first rise for 8-12 hours at room temperature. If your house is cold, try to find a warm spot. If your house is hot, prepare for the dough to double in size in less time (even closer to 6 hours!).
You can transfer the dough to the fridge after the bulk ferment the next day if you're not yet ready to shape and bake the sandwich rolls.
The next day, divide the dough into 8 equal pieces with a dough scraper and shape them. If the dough sticks to your fingers a little, try wetting your hands with warm water. On a lightly floured surface, flatten each dough portion into a rectangle, aiming for a thickness of around ¼ inch. Then roll it into a compact shape (like a hot dog bun), sealing the ends by pinching them together.
Place the formed rolls on a baking sheet lined with parchment paper, ensuring that the seam side is facing downward. Let them rise until they almost double in size.
The second rise could take anywhere from 1 - 3 hours, depending on the temperature in your environment and the level of activity in your sourdough starter.
When the rolls have almost doubled in size, preheat your oven to 375°F (190°C).
Optional: Do a slash or two with a sharp knife or a razor. Since the sandwich rolls don't expand that much in the oven, this step is optional, but the lines do look pretty.
Also optional: Spray the rolls with some water to create crusty outsides and soft insides.
Bake them at 375°F (190°C) for 17 - 22 minutes (depending on the strength of your oven), until they are golden brown.
Allow them to cool (the best way to cool them is by placing them on a wire rack) and enjoy your perfect sandwich bread!
Notes
The flour you use, the altitude you live at, the humidity of the air in your kitchen...all this and more will affect how much flour you need in a recipe (a more technical term is the dough's hydration). So don't be afraid to add flour in order to get the dough to pull away from the bowl's sides and achieve a stretchy consistency! If you see (and feel) that your dough is shaggy and unmanageable, add a little flour and see what happens
Substitution Notes:
Butter - instead of butter, you can use olive oil, but the rolls may not be as soft (but they will still be as moist).
Flour - I successfully made this recipe using an even greater amount of whole wheat flour instead of white flour. The rolls did end up stiffer, but tastier in my opinion. So you can definitely up your whole wheat flour portion if you want to.
Water - you can substitute buttermilk or whey for the water (if you have them as leftovers). You may need a bit less flour in that case.
Storage:
At room temperature, they're best stored in an airtight bag/container. They stay fresh for 3-4 days in the fridge.
You can even freeze them for 1-2 months, although to be fair, I've never tried it with these. We simply eat them way too quickly!